There's a common misconception (or hype) about our Jewish community that supposedly has been “revived". Many newspapers and magazines have been talking about Germany's - and specifically Berlin's - recent Jewish “revival" after its destruction by the Nazis.
Is it really so? And what should you expect when coming to Berlin for the first time?
Before the Nazis came to power, Berlin's Jewish community had about 160,000 official members. There were also non-affiliated Jews, just like today. Except today, the community has just about 10,000 members. Not really a revival.
But it's not just a huge number gap. It's also about the personal background of the people that actually make the community what it is. Eight decades ago, the majority of Jews in Berlin were born here and their mother tongue was German. There were quite a few immigrants, but that was still the exception, not the rule. It was, at least in its own self-understanding, very much a German-Jewish community, often more German than Jewish. That was the context of famous people such as Albert Einstein. Unlike the typically orthodox/traditional immigrants, the local Jews affiliated themselves with the Reform movement in one way or another.
Nowadays, the majority of Jews in Berlin are immigrants, who - just like myself - were not born here and whose mother tongue is not German. There are some families that can actually trace their roots back to that glorious time before the Nazis, usually descendants of Jews that left Germany before the war and came back after the war (for various reasons, often having to do with cultural difficulties in their countries of “exile" or with family property that could be claimed in Berlin). But that's the exception, not the rule. Everybody else was either born to immigrants or, in most cases, is an immigrant.
* * *
The post-war Jewish immigration to Germany in general and to Berlin in particular can be broken down to four phases:
1. Displaced Persons
After the war, hundreds of thousands of Jewish DPs came from Eastern Europe to the American DP camps. Unlike most DPs, who left Germany when they were finally permitted to do so, some actually stayed here. Usually it had to do with business and similar reasons, without any intention to establish a new Jewish future in Germany. Those were survivors whose world was lost in the Holocaust and who lived here “on their suitcases".
Their children were born here and grew up as “German" Jews, but were still looked down upon by the not so many “original German" Jews who came back. Later on, specifically in the 50's, more Polish Jews came, having left Poland because of the anti-Semitism of the communist regime.
It's hard to estimate the numbers of these pre-unification communities, but in Germany as a whole there were about 25-30 thousand, most of them in West Germany and about several hundreds in the GDR (in 1933, there were about. 520,000 Jews in Germany).
2. German converts
In comparison to other countries or to pre-war Germany, we're talking about unusually high numbers of conversions. Since the predominantly Yiddish-speaking DPs couldn't really take on the role of the missing German Jews, the lasting vacuum began to attract non-Jews. “2nd generation Germans", i.e. the children of the war generation, began to enter the empty stage as of the 70's. For many of them, it wasn't just about a Jewish life, but about a career. They often began to fulfill public functions in ways that wouldn't have been possible for converts in other countries and under normal circumstances. At least for the German majority, they became the new “Jewish voice", perceived - not against their will - as authentic representatives and true heirs of the murdered German-Jewish legacy. In Berlin for example, the congregation that gathers at the Jewish community center (the so-called “New Synagogue") is a well-known center for non-Jews who want to convert or have already done so, including the rabbi and other functionaries.
3. Soviet Jews
During and after the collapse of the USSR, Jews had a very unique opportunity to immigrate to Germany. Nowadays, this is by far the most significant group in our Jewish landscape. Unlike the Displaced Persons, these Jews made a conscious decision to begin a new life in Germany. From 1990 to 2005, Germany allowed Jews from former Soviet countries to immigrate to Germany as “refugees" and, eventually, become German citizens. This was not based on religious criteria, but on the applicants' Jewish nationality (in Europe, nationality is not the same as citizenship - we explain that in our article about national minorities in Europe and in Germany).
The official reason for allowing this Jewish immigration was that they were persecuted in the former USSR (where there was a rise in Antisemitism). But since they could have gone to Israel, it wasn't really about that. The real reason was that the massive immigration of Jews out of the former USSR (usually to Israel or to North America) presented a “once-in-a-lifetime" chance to “revive" Jewish life in Germany by “importing" Jews from the last large Jewish reservoir in the continent. Yet there were quotas for the number of “refugees" that could come each year. In fact, those that wanted to go to Germany usually had to wait in the former USSR for several years for their turn. Instead of escaping immediately to Israel, they preferred to stay in the former USSR - where according to Germany's official argument they were in danger - because by leaving too early they would have lost the option to be “refugees" in Germany. Generally speaking, it was a rather “old" immigration, because the young Jews often went to North-America or Israel.
The chart includes both Jewish immigrants as well as non-Jewish family members of Jewish immigrants
Did it work? Yes and no. It did raise the number of Jews very significantly to about 110,000 all over Germany. But to be honest, it didn't “revive” much. Firstly, because these were people whose heritage didn't relate to German-Jewish culture. As Eastern-European Jews, their tradition had nothing to do with Reform Judaism. And more importantly, seven decades of communism disconnected them from their Jewish roots. Germany expected them to resettle and simply “be Jewish". But for most of them, that became a real challenge - also because many were married to gentiles and came to Germany with their non-Jewish family members.
In some places, like in Berlin, there was already a Jewish community that tried to support and help, but the massive Russian speaking immigration basically turned the Jews that were already there into a minority in their own community, causing a lot of inner conflicts that still go on. Although many Soviet Jews lived in Ukraine, they are now generally referred to as “the Russians" and are sometimes looked down upon by the “German Jews" that were here before - namely the children of the Eastern-European Displaced Persons...
In most places there was no Jewish community before this immigration. The often clueless “refugees" were sent by the German authorities to create Jewish communities. We now have 105 of them in Germany - most of which only exist thanks to the Russian speaking emigration. In Berlin, where there was a Jewish community before 1990, the percentage of Russian speaking Jews is considered rather low - about 85% of the community members. The vast majority is not religious, but many do show up for the High Holidays. Eventually, the massive immigration was basically brought to an end by requiring “Jewish refugees" to have some knowledge of German before being given the permission to resettle. This was done in order to let the Jewish communities cope with the immense change that had already taken place.
4. Contemporary Expats
The most recent contribution to Jewish life in Berlin - not so much elsewhere in Germany - is thanks to the ongoing immigration of American and Israeli expats. Many come for a short time (from several months to a couple of years) and don't actually settle here, so it's not a real immigration in the usual sense of the word. They are typically young and come here to work (often as programmers), to do art (often musicians) or because of their academic studies (like myself). One synagogue in Berlin (“Fraenkelufer") was quite forgotten and inactive until it was discovered by a group of young expats. But generally speaking, young Jewish expats are not active in Berlin's Jewish community, at least not in the religious sense of the term.
* * *
So what does it all mean? With the overwhelming majority being immigrants, our current community is not, and cannot, be a “revival" of the pre-war German-Jewish community. The community you'll find here should probably not be described as a community of “German Jews", but rather as “Jews in Germany", whose descendants might one day become “German Jews" in one way or another, but at the moment, we're really not there yet. It is not a coincidence that the umbrella organization of our Jewish communities - the Central Council - isn't called “The Central Council of Jewish Germans" or “The Central Council of German Jews", but simply - and accurately - “The Central Council of Jews in Germany".
We're often asked by our guests: Why did the Jews come back? The answer is, as you now know, that they actually didn't. We didn't come “back", because - with very few exceptions - we are not the German Jews that were once here. We were never here before we immigrated.
Currently, many Jewish communities in Germany are shrinking again. There is a very gradual, but constant decrease of members in Jewish communities across the country. Berlin, with its image as a hip city attracting young Jews from America, Israel and other countries, is less affected by this phenomenon than other communities - yet even here, the Jewish community has decreased from almost 11,000 members in 2008 to about 9.500 in 2017. This is the bottom line and without the immigration from other countries, the shrinking would only be faster.
Negative growth in Germany's largest Jewish community
So why are Germany's Jewish communities shrinking? There are several reasons. To begin with, many of the Soviet immigrants that created the “Jewish revival” hype to begin with, were actually older people. Young Jews in the former USSR often preferred to go to Israel or to America, while Germany was left with an upside-down Jewish demographic pyramid consisting mostly of Jews who will not be having more children. On top of that, young Jews in Germany - those who came as children from the former USSR or were even born here, and who are now in the right age to make the next Jewish generation - don't always want to stay in Germany. As you surely know, Jews are not the only group of immigrants and, in light of the developments since 2015, more young Jewish adults “opt out” and prefer to build their future elsewhere, specifically in Israel or in America. In fact, a survey conducted by the European Union's Agency for Fundamental Rights found that 44% of the Jewish respondents in Germany “have considered emigrating in the past five years because they did not feel safe there as Jews” (see more about that in our article about Antisemitism in Germany).
These two phenomena - rapidly aging communities that were not sustainable to begin with, combined with increasing emigration to other countries - result in an astonishing demographic deficit: In 2017, about 1,500 people died in Germany's Jewish communities while just about 250 were born, and this despairing ratio has been pretty much the same for quite a few years. In other words: Each year, for every baby born in one of Germany's Jewish communities, about 6 people die.
Is this gradual, yet constant development somehow reversible? Would the immigration-based “Jewish revival in Germany” actually create a new Jewish future in a lasting, sustainable way - or was it just a short episode that wouldn't turn the wheel around? Only time will tell.
PS. Our Excel charts are based on the official statistics provided by the “Central Welfare Agency of the Jews in Germany”.